Best Halal Pizza in Toronto & the GTA
Our top pick for halal pizza right now is Al Madina Halal Pizza & Bakery in Scarborough — every spot below has been visited and verified.
Halal pizza in Toronto ranges from the honest Scarborough institution open until 1 AM to the wood-fired spot trying to do something more. The ranking separates the spots that genuinely understand dough from the ones coasting on halal meat and delivery volume. What the best halal pizza places here share: a crust that has some character, cheese that pulls properly, and toppings that don't weigh the whole thing down. The Hit List ranks the spots where the pizza is the reason to go — not just the closest option that's open.
Al Madina Halal Pizza & Bakery
Affordable halal pizza, wings, and samosas
Toppings
Premium fully halal pizza, bacon cheeseburger, popcorn chicken, and sweet potato fries
Pizza Land Halal
Premium halal pizza with diverse toppings
Bismillah Pizza
Halal pizza and classic toppings
How we judge halal pizza
Crust is the foundation. A halal pizza with a limp, pale base doesn't make the list regardless of topping quality. We want leopard-spotted bottom, structural integrity through the first three bites, and a rim with some chew. After crust: the sauce-to-cheese ratio, whether the halal meat is cooked to order or pre-cooked then reheated, and whether the overall build is intentional or just piled on. Value is weighted more heavily here than in other categories because pizza is a value category — a $30 pie had better justify the gap from the $18 one.
The Halal Hit List judges pizza spots on actual visits — not Google ratings, not reviews, not popularity. Every entry has been visited, photographed, and given an honest verdict: Hit, Solid, Decent, Borderline, or Miss.
Halal pizza in Toronto — FAQs
What is the best halal pizza in Toronto?
Al Madina Halal Pizza in Wexford, Scarborough is currently the top-ranked halal pizza on the Hit List. It's a late-night Scarborough institution — open until 1 AM daily — and the hot honey pizza is the signature order. Fully halal, verified in person.
Where can I get halal pizza in Scarborough?
Al Madina Halal Pizza on Wexford Ave is the top pick for halal pizza in Scarborough. It's open until 1 AM every day, making it one of the few quality halal options after 11 PM in the east end. Bismillah Pizza is another Scarborough staple worth knowing.
Is the pizza at halal spots in Toronto actually fully halal?
The spots on the Halal Hit List are verified fully halal — the whole kitchen, not just the toppings. Some pizza chains in Toronto use halal meat on a kitchen that also handles pork products; we don't rank those. Every spot on this list has been confirmed in person for full kitchen halal status.
Are there halal wood-fired or artisan pizza spots in Toronto?
Yes. The halal pizza scene has moved beyond takeout-only spots. Check the full pizza category on the Hit List for the current top-ranked options across different styles — from late-night Scarborough to sit-down pies.
What should I order at a halal pizza spot in Toronto?
Order the signature — the house special or whatever the spot is known for. At a late-night Scarborough spot like Al Madina, hot honey is the move. Ask if there's a daily special; the best halal pizza places rotate toppings and the specials are often where the kitchen shows off.