Toronto's halal smash burger scene is genuinely strong — and most people are still sleeping on it. The gap between a great smash burger and a mediocre one is dramatic: you either get that proper caramelized crust with cheese melted into the meat, or you get a flat disc that tastes like it was prepped at 10 AM. The spots below have figured it out.
No. 1 — Oklahoma Burgers
The best halal smash burger in the city. What makes Oklahoma Burgers different isn't just technique — it's the style. This is an onion-forward smash burger, which means the onions are smashed directly into the patty on the griddle, caramelizing into the meat as it cooks. The result is a level of sweetness and depth you don't get from a standard smash.
Then there's the Bone Marrow sauce. It's genuinely unique — rich, savoury, and the kind of thing you'll think about after. No other halal burger spot in the city is doing this.
Order: The Bone Marrow (BM) Burger. That's the one. Don't leave without trying it.
What sets it apart: The onion-forward Oklahoma style and the BM sauce together. Two things no other halal burger in the city is doing at this level.
No. 2 — Burgers Park
A serious smash burger that punches above its price point. Burgers Park keeps it focused — the patty quality is strong, the toppings are fresh, and the Park Burger is a well-built sandwich from bun to bottom.
Don't skip the poutine. It's genuinely good and one of the better halal poutines you'll find at a burger spot in the city.
Order: The Park Burger. Add poutine on the side — you won't regret it.
What sets it apart: The value. You're getting a quality smash burger experience at a price that makes it an easy regular spot, not a special occasion.
The Sleeper — Simba's Hot Chicken
Everyone goes to Simba's for the hot chicken sandwich (as they should), but there's a smash burger on the menu that most regulars have never ordered. It's a solid burger at a price that makes sense — around $10–12 depending on the build — and it's a legitimate option if you're in a group and someone doesn't want heat.
One thing to know: the burger comes with jalapeños by default. We personally love it that way, but if jalapeños aren't your thing, just ask without. It still holds up.
Order: The smash burger while your group gets the hot chicken. Still get the crinkle-cut fries regardless.
What to look for in a halal smash burger
A few things separate the good from the great:
The crust. The whole point of smashing the patty is maximising contact with the griddle and creating a Maillard crust. If the outside of the patty isn't visibly dark and textured, something went wrong. A pale, smooth patty means it wasn't smashed hard enough or the flat-top wasn't hot enough.
The cheese situation. American cheese melted directly on the patty — not added at the end — is the move. The cheese should be absorbed into the meat, not sitting on top like an afterthought.
The bun. A soft bun matters. Brioche or a potato bun is the move — you want something that's pillowy enough to absorb the fat and juice without falling apart. A dense or dry bun ruins the ratio no matter how good the patty is.
The bun-to-patty ratio. Most smash burgers work best as doubles. A single patty is mostly bun. Two thinner smashed patties give you the right meat-to-bread ratio and twice the crust surface.
The price. A quality smash burger with a double stack, cheese, and sauce should run you $13–18 in Toronto right now. If it's $20+ for a basic double, the value equation is off.
Follow on TikTok for new burger verdicts as they drop.
See every spot on TikTok
The Halal Hit List drops verdicts on TikTok before they hit the site.
Follow @halalhitlist →